Electric vs. Hydraulic Lift Gates: Maintenance Needs Compared

In commercial trucking, lift gates are essential for efficient loading and unloading. Whether you’re delivering pallets of produce, industrial equipment, or retail freight, a reliable lift gate ensures safe handling at the job site. But not all lift gates are created equal.

Operators typically choose between electric and hydraulic lift gates based on load demands, truck class, and application. However, one factor that often gets overlooked is maintenance. Choosing the wrong system—or neglecting the one you have—can result in breakdowns, safety risks, or costly delays, especially in a city like Chicago, IL, where extreme weather and stop-and-go traffic accelerate wear.

This article will compare electric and hydraulic lift gate systems, breaking down the maintenance needs, common issues, and practical service schedules to keep your fleet running efficiently.

What’s the Difference Between Electric and Hydraulic Lift Gates?

Understanding the core operating differences is key to understanding why their maintenance needs differ drastically.

Electric Lift Gates

These lift gates operate using electric motors and mechanical lifting mechanisms like chains or screw drives. The truck’s battery supplies power, and movement is controlled via switches and limiters.

• Typical uses: Light- to medium-duty applications
• Lifting capacity: Usually 1,000–2,500 lbs
• Control system: Electric switches and relays

Strengths:

• Lightweight and compact
• Quieter operation
• No fluid-related messes
• Easier DIY diagnostics

Weaknesses:

• Limited power for heavier loads
• Electrical corrosion is common in winter climates
• Relies on a consistent battery voltage

Hydraulic Lift Gates

These are powered by a hydraulic pump that pushes pressurized fluid through cylinders to raise and lower the platform. The system includes a reservoir, pump, fluid lines, and actuating pistons.

• Typical uses: Medium- to heavy-duty operations
• Lifting capacity: 2,500–6,000+ lbs
• Control system: Hydraulic control valves and switches

Strengths:

• Stronger lifting power
• Consistent performance with heavy loads
• Ideal for industrial use

Weaknesses:

• Requires hydraulic fluid checks
• Higher complexity = more potential failure points
• More expensive to repair

Maintenance Considerations for Both Systems

When comparing electric vs. hydraulic lift gates, preventive maintenance, seasonal reliability, and repair frequency are the most crucial factors.

Electrical System Maintenance (Electric Gates)

Electric gates require consistent upkeep on their wiring, motor, and switches.

• Wiring harness inspections should be done every 90 days. Look for cracking, corrosion, or fraying.
• Switches and relays can corrode or stick, especially after snow and salt exposure.
• Battery load testing should be part of your routine. Low voltage will stall the lift or make it unresponsive.
• Limit switches must be recalibrated or replaced when the gate begins to stop mid-cycle or overshoot.

Chicago winters can corrode terminals fast, especially if snow and brine are allowed to sit on the lift gate overnight. Applying dielectric grease to terminals and sealing connectors with heat shrink tubing helps reduce electrical failures.

Hydraulic System Maintenance (Hydraulic Gates)

Hydraulic lift gates demand more from a maintenance perspective but offer durability under load.

• Check fluid levels monthly, especially after significant temperature swings. Hydraulic fluid expands and contracts with heat and cold.
• Inspect hoses every 30-60 days for cracking, swelling, or leaks.
• Watch for pump whine or hesitation—these are signs of fluid aeration or pump wear.
• Flush hydraulic fluid yearly (or 2x per year in cold climates). Contaminated fluid leads to seal wear and pressure loss.

One major issue in cold climates like Illinois is fluid thickening. Gates may become sluggish in sub-zero temps. Always use winter-grade hydraulic oil, and consider insulating lines and the reservoir.

Shared Maintenance Tasks for Both Systems

While their power sources differ, both lift gate types share several maintenance needs:

Hinges and Pivot Points

Lubricate every moving joint monthly. A dry hinge or stuck pivot can misalign the gate and overwork the lifting system.

Pro tip: Use a lithium-based grease rated for low temperatures and high pressure.

Mounting Hardware and Brackets

Check all bolts and frame mount points every quarter. Look for:

• Rust around mounting holes
• Loose hardware
• Weld cracks

Any misalignment can cause binding, increased motor strain, or even platform collapse.

Common Failure Points & Troubleshooting Tips

Electric Lift Gates

• Problem: The gate won’t lift
  Cause: Dead battery, failed motor, or blown fuse
  Fix: Test voltage, inspect switch wiring, and check fuse continuity.
• Problem: Jerky motion
  Cause: Motor gears or chain misalignment
  Fix: Lubricate the drive train or adjust the tension.
• Problem: Stops mid-cycle
  Cause: Faulty limit switch
  Fix: Replace or recalibrate switch settings.

Hydraulic Lift Gates

• Problem: Lift gate lowers too fast
  Cause: Worn check valve or air in the system
  Fix: Bleed hydraulic lines and inspect the check valve.
• Problem: Slow or weak lifting
  Cause: Low fluid or worn pump
  Fix: Refill or flush fluid; replace the pump if it's noisy.
• Problem: Leaks from the ram seals
  Cause: Worn seals or contaminated fluid
  Fix: Seal kit replacement and fluid flush

Which Gate Should You Choose?

An electric lift gate may be ideal if your business moves lighter loads, runs mostly in urban areas, or needs lower maintenance complexity.

On the other hand, if you're lifting heavy freight, frequently loading pallets, or operating in rugged conditions, a hydraulic lift gate offers the strength and durability you’ll need.

Mixed fleets? It might be wise to standardize one gate type across your trucks to simplify training and inventory stocking for replacement parts.

Conclusion

Your lift gate is only as good as the care it receives. Whether you rely on an electric model or a hydraulic powerhouse, staying on top of preventive maintenance will ensure fewer breakdowns, less downtime, and safer operations for your crew.

At On Site Mechanical Services in Chicago, IL, we specialize in electric and hydraulic lift gate repair. We also offer on-location fleet service that keeps your trucks on the road and out of the shop. Don’t wait for a gate failure to shut down your delivery—schedule your lift gate maintenance today.

‍